This article was updated on January 6th, 2017.

Ford is concerned that the new API CK-4 diesel oil spec does not mandate enough wear control additives. But fear not, there is a distinct work-around.

There’s a bit of controversy brewing regarding the brand new API diesel engine oil specifications that debut for 2017. Starting in December, the American Petroleum Institute (API) will start granting licenses for two new diesel engine oil specs. The API CK-4 specification will supersede the API CJ-4 spec that debuted back in 2006. A new low-viscosity spec for over-the-road transport trucks call API FA-4 will also be released. So why is there a controversy?

Ford has conducted in-house testing on API CK-4 and FA-4 formulations in their Powerstroke diesel engines. They were not pleased with the results. The FA-4 oils simply did not provide effective viscosity protection (read: too thin) and some CK-4 oils did not contain enough phosphorous to provide acceptable valve-train wear protection.

Phosphorous is a vital anti-wear agent in diesel engine oils. The current API CJ-4 spec mandates a maximum phosphorous content of 0.12%. This generally works out to over 1000 parts per million (ppm). Ford is finding that motor oil with a phosphorous content under 1000 ppm is causing excessive wear. The new API CK-4 spec mandates a phosphorous limit of 0.08%. This can leave some formulations with less than the 1000 ppm that Ford would like to see. But there is a way to avoid the new low phosphorous limit and still use API CK-4 oils in Powerstroke diesel engines.

Here is the vital distinction. The API is suggesting this lower phosphorous limit when a motor oil maker wishes to carry both the API CK-4 diesel specification AND the API SN passenger car/gasoline engine specification on the label. As the API SN limit for phosphorous is 0.8%, the API is requiring that any diesel engine oil also carrying the passenger car/gasoline engine spec must meet this lower limit. The good news is that “stand alone” diesel engine oils that do not label their product as meeting the API SN (or any other passenger car spec) can have a higher phosphorous limit of 0.12%.

In other words, as Ford is suggesting that the previous generation API CJ-4 oils do contain an acceptable allotment of phosphorous, “diesel only” API CK-4 oils should also be fine. Ford is coming up with their own diesel spec to clear up any confusion. It will be called Ford WSS-M2C171-F1. We can speculate that motor oils meeting this spec will either be API CK-4 oils that do not have the API SN designation or older API CJ-4 products.

API CK-4 Phosphorous Issue Update- January 6th, 2017

Further clarification from the American Petroleum Institute. They tell us that 40-weight diesel engine oils (such as 5W-40, 15W-40, 0W-40) can have both the API CK-4 and API SN specs and still abide by the higher API CK-4 phosphorus limit. On the other hand, 0W-30, 5W-30 and 10W-30 engine oils carrying both the API SN and API CK-4 specs have to abide by the lower SN phosphorous limit of 800 ppm.

AMSOIL Offers Safe API CK-4 Engine Oil For Ford Powerstroke

AMSOIL API-CK-4 Diesel Engine Oils

AMSOIL’s 2017 API CK-4 Diesel Engine Oil Line-up

AMSOIL is releasing a full suite of brand new diesel engine oils in early 2017 that will meet the API CK-4 spec. Most will also be Ford WSS-M2C171-F1 compliant. We can only speculate as to whether these oils will also carry that API SN gasoline engine specification to make them more convenient for fleets. We know that the upcoming Signature Series Max Protection 5W-30 will also carry the API SN spec. It will be interesting to see if this product also carries the Ford spec. We will go out on a limb and guess that most of the upcoming line-up will be “diesel only” so that they can contain the 0.12% dose of phosphorus. We’ll know more in the weeks to come. AMSOIL has already indicated that they will have API CK-4 product choices that will be undeniably safe for all model year Ford Powerstroke engines.

Conclusion

The API is suggesting that the CK-4 oil standard will offer improvements in terms of oil longevity, shear stability and deposit control over the current CJ-4 spec. Once Ford releases their new diesel oil specification, Powerstroke owners should have an easier time finding safe formulations with the very latest motor oil technology.

AMSOIL vs. Royal Purple vs. Mobil 1

A heavyweight battle between three perennial motor oil  favorites.

AMSOIL, Royal Purple and Mobil 1 have been long considered to be top-end motor oil brands. A recent independent, standardized lab test was conducted to determine how well each brand could combat deposit formation. Here are the contenders.

  • AMSOIL Signature Series 5W-30 Synthetic Motor Oil
  • Royal Purple API 5W-30 Synthetic Motor Oil
  • Mobil 1 Extended Performance 5W-30 Synthetic Motor Oil

About The Test

AMSOIL, Royal Purple, Mobil 1 Deposit Test ResultsThe TEOST 33C test (also known as “ASTM D6335”) is a laboratory test apparatus that replicates the operating conditions of a turbo-charged engine. Engine oil is circulated through the machine at fluctuating temperatures between 200°C and 480°C for two hours. Moist air and nitrous oxide is added to the oil. This duplicates internal engine conditions. The weight of the carbon deposits created during the test determines the result.

Note the test results on your left. AMSOIL Signature Series 5W-30 Synthetic Motor Oil generated just 7.0 mg of deposits. Royal Purple API 5W-30 ended with 25.4 mg and Mobil 1 Extended Performance 5W-30 created a whopping 28.2 mg of carbon deposits. The API SN and ILSAC GF-5 motor oil industry standards dictate a TEOST 33C limit of 30 mg. As a result, Royal Purple and Mobil 1 barely make the grade in the deposit test. AMSOIL Signature Series 5W-30 delivers a spectacular result.

Why Is Deposit Control Important?

Engine deposit control has always been vital, but never more important than today. Today’s car buyer expects maximum fuel economy and reasonable horsepower output. The solution for many car makers is the turbocharger. Turbochargers spin at upwards of 250,000 revolutions per minute and can create exhaust gas temperatures in the 1000°C range. Using an engine oil that can withstand these rigors is paramount. Even very tiny carbon particles in the engine oil can eventually wreak havoc on expensive turbocharger bearings.

AMSOIL Signature Series 5W-30 Synthetic Motor Oil delivers 3 to 4 times the deposit fighting power of the high-end offerings from Mobil 1 and Royal Purple. Imagine how budget-priced engine oils might perform in this test? If you have a turbo-charged engine, do not cheap out on motor oil. An ultra-high quality motor oil like AMSOIL Signature Series could be the best preventative measure money can buy. Expect the same turbo performance from Signature Series 0W-20, 5W-20, 10W-30, 0W-40 and 5W-50.

Not All Synthetic Oils Are Equal

Even the (supposedly) top-end Mobil 1 Extended Life and Royal Purple synthetic oils performed dismally in this common, standardized deposit test. You get what you pay for and AMSOIL consistently delivers.